Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Election For Sale

Thursday in Afghanistan promises to be a day of reckoning for not only Hamid Karzai and his government but also for larger Western efforts to turn a state that's existed in a haphazard tribal system for centuries into a functioning democracy. Karzai is running for his second term as Afghanistan's President since he was hand picked by the US, then under President Bush, for his charismatic and strong political nature. However, since he won the first Presidential election in 2004, Karzai's government has suffered routine setbacks in battling insurgents as well as widespread corruption while also failing to extend its authority beyond the capital city of Kabul.

But, corruption within and actual authority of the government are only two parts of the legitimacy issue in Thursday's elections. The legitimacy of the elections themselves is in peril due to increased violence in towns around voting polls as well as direct threats from the Taliban and other insurgent groups. Also, election monitors won't be able to be present in dangerous areas, presenting an opportunity for vote fraud. But, the ultimate challenge to legitimacy will be the outcome. More than one candidate has employed political manipulation tactics by claiming violent unrest will occur if they are not the winner or overtly accusing Karzai of stealing the election. These types of claims and political manipulations increase the likelihood of violence in the instance that the elections are not decisive and legitimacy challenges are not addressed properly and openly.

The gut check here is very anxious. This election is the make or break point for President Obama's redoubled efforts in Afghanistan and the future of any Afghani government, plain and simple. There will certainly be legitimacy challenges following Thursday's vote, and, if they aren't handled properly, violent unrest a la Iran is a very real possibility. US and allied forces are already involved in a protracted battle against resurgent Taliban and Al Qaeda forces; having to deal with violence by citizens not affiliated with insurgency would make an already nightmarish war zone nearly impossible to navigate, much less subdue. Another valid issue is how the losers will react. While there are more than forty challengers facing Karzai, only a few have a real chance. If Karzai wins, will those few leaders concede or push legitimacy challenges and urge protest among their followers? Too much is riding on this election for Thursday to go off without a hitch.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Unstable Ally

In the US's campaign in Afghanistan, much is dependent on our ally to the South East, Pakistan. Since most of the fighting between US and allied forces is taking place along the mountainous and desolate border between Afghanistan and Pakistan, the Taliban, Al Qaeda and other insurgents have enjoyed unfettered movement across the border and made outlying villages in the Pashtun province their main recruiting grounds. In fact, you may remember the foreign policy fiasco during the 2008 Presidential elections when Sarah Palin was "ambushed" in a restaurant by a voter who asked her if she would pursue terrorists across the border into Pakistan with air support to which she replied that she would. US excursions across the border into Pakistan was and is still a major problem between the two countries.

During the Bush administration, the campaign in Afghanistan, arguably much more important than Iraq, suffered a great deal of backsliding. But, Pakistan, then under Musharraf, was more subordinate to the US in terms of military action. However, towards the end of the Bush administration, air strikes and other excursions across the border became a major rallying cry of extremist Islamic groups that slowly pushed Musharraf to the breaking point. Following his manipulations of the government (such as illegally declaring state of emergency powers, attempting to dismiss the Chief Justice, and stacking the high court in his favor) and other political functions (such as postponing the elections planned for November 2008), Musharraf was forced out of office by both Islamic extremist groups and legitimate political parties who would no longer stand on the sidelines and suffer military dictatorship.

However, as soon as Musharraf's government became unstable, Islamic extremist groups seized on the opportunity to increase their size and influence, most notably the Taliban and Al Qaeda. But, Afghanistan and the US aren't the only targets of Pakistani terrorist groups. The terrorist attack in Mumbai, India last year that halted the peace process between the two countries was perpetrated by an Islamic militant group based out of Pakistan, Lashkar-e-Taiba. Pakistan seems to be slowly losing control over its own security when it can't even bring charges against the alleged leader of Lashkar-e-Taiba, Hafiz Saeed.

The gut check here is much scarier than the growing numbers of terrorist groups like the Taliban and Al Qaeda. In the past two years, Pakistani nuclear weapons facilities have been attacked by terrorist three times. Given that the relationship between India and Pakistan has proven to be one of the world's three most likely scenarios for regional or global nuclear war when it was just the governments of the two countries going at it, the idea of a terrorist group obtaining even one nuclear weapon from Pakistan is downright terrifying. Never mind just buying one from a rogue state like Iran or North Korea, terrorists have a better chance of straight up overwhelming an already unstable security mechanism to the point that Pakistan loses control of their nuclear facilities. We shouldn't be afraid of a state like Iran that doesn't have nukes yet. We should be afraid of a state that loses complete control over the nukes they already have.

Thursday, August 6, 2009

New Promises, Old War

Today, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton traveled to Africa to issue a new pledge of support for Somalia in its on-going conflict with insurgent group Al Shabaab. Secretary Clinton also issued a sharp rebuke to neighboring Eritrea for its alleged support of Al Shabaab and promised to pursue sanctions. But, at a time when our armed forces are stretched thin and entirely committed to the campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan, what kind of support can we actually give?

Somalia has been plagued by war since the 1970's and has essentially been under failed state status since the beginning of the Somali Civil War in the early 1990's. Extremist Islamic groups began consolidating power by recruiting local war lords from 2004 to present. Ethiopia intervened and, together with African Union forces as well as international military support including US gunships, shut down the radical Islamic pseudo government called the Islamic Courts Union. But, in early 2009, Ethiopia withdrew, leaving behind the AU peacekeepers who were wholly unprepared for the coming rewnewal of conflict.

Here in the US, we only recently gained insight into new developments in Somalia when several Somali immigrants suddenly returned to Somalia to take part in the resurgent civil war. The catalyst was when one of the naturalized US citizens returned to Somalia and became the first American to ever carry out a suicide bombing. Now, Somalia is suddenly back on the map in terms of foreign policy. The country is under constant assault from a terrorist organization (Al Shabaab) known to have ties to Al Qaeda.

So why don't we have troops there? Simply put, we don't have the man power. The US can't afford to send valuable logistical resources and troops to Somalia when we are already falling behind in Afghanistan and trying to finish out the campaign in Iraq. Also, the infamous Black Hawk Down scenario is a sharp reminder of how easy it can be to get bogged down in Somalia.

The gut check here is rather bitter. Somalia is one of those places where we should have done it right the first time, but politics got in the way of conducting military opperations. Now, years later, Somalia is a breeding ground for Al Qaeda. But, the fact that the AU is beginning to stand on its own changes the situation dramatically. If an AU lead operation were to be successful in Somalia with help from the international community, the AU would gain extreme amounts of credibility in conflict solving. Right now, Secretary Clinton's diplomatic strategy, putting the pressure on those who supply Al Shabaab (allegedly Eritrea) and other insurgent groups, is the prudent course. If it gets to the point where we have to send military forces, I hope we send something harder to hit with an RPG than a black hawk.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Operation Treadmill

While the world was preoccupied with Iraq, Afghanistan quietly became more and more lost. Now, with Iraq winding down, the upcoming round of elections is providing a critical review of democratic progress in Afghanistan. With Karzai facing down two main challengers in a field of contestants, the elections themselves are far from decided, much less guaranteed to even happen given a new outbreak of violence. At issue is whether or not the US has succeeded in creating a secure environment in which democracy can flourish.

Since the invasion of Iraq in 2003, the US presence in Afghanistan has done little to provide security. The Taliban as well as other insurgent groups have enjoyed tacit freedom in the no-mans-land area on the boarder betwen Pakistan and Afghanistan due to the extreme complexity of the terrain. As a result, the Taliban and other insurgent groups have been able to essentially ressurect their forces and produce a new wave of violence that is threatening the stability of the upcoming Afghani elections. In fact, reports indicate that Taliban and Afghani insurgents have reached a new level of sophistication in guerrilla warfare that has significantly increased their operating range, their combat effectiveness, and their overall lethality.

Part of the reason the mission Afghanistan has slid so far backwards is the policies and strategies of the Bush adminstration. Under Bush, the US basically contracted local war lords to provide intelligence and regional security. As a result, the war lords were basically given the freedom to enlarge their private armies and run their opium poppy trade, leading to a massive boom in the Afghani heroin trade. This drug trade boom put money directly into the hands of Al Qaeda and the Taliban. In response to this backsliding, President Obama announced his new plan for Afghanistan at the end of May and later developed a new drug policy.

But, even if his strategic plan enjoys marginal success, it is no guarantee that the US's political plans for Afghanistan succeed. In 2001, Karzai looked like the best choice to lead Afghanistan given that he would work closely with the US and had the charisma and character needed to lead. Now, he presides over what is largely seen as a corrupt government. The lesson that the US has continuously failed to learn is that we can't simply choose who should lead a country, the leader has to be organically chosen.

The gut check here is that Afghanistan is in a very precarious position. US forces have a long way to go to guarantee stability. If it's too dangerous, the elections might not be viable. If it is stable enough but the US is too involved, the elections will be seen as biased or even rigged. But, if the US holds too much back and the Taliban, Al Qaeda, or some other insurgent group have too much freedom to influence the voting, the Taliban could enjoy a political revitalization as well. The key is to provide a secure atmosphere so the elections can be held free of violence while not influencing the voting in any way.

Saturday, August 1, 2009

Kangaroo Court

Today, Iran held trials for numerous individuals involved in protests after the recent Presidential elections. Those arrested include civillians active in the post-elections protests and prominent pro-reform politicians, indicating that anyone who opposes the government is not safe. No verdicts or sentences have been given yet, but the details and allegations from the trials that have already come out show that this is clearly no court of law.

The fifteen page indicment alleges that the defendants attacked government forces and buildings, have links to armed rebel groups, and conspired against the ruling system. More accusations allege that the groups that the pro-reform politicians represent took money from foreign entities (read: the West) in a year long plot to bring about a velvet revolution. Nevermind that the pro-reform parties might have real interests in changing the course of Iranian politics, they were clearly trying to overthrow the government by engaging in a peaceful, democratic elections process.

The gut check here is disgusting. Ahmadinejad's regime calls this a trial, but it's clearly all for show. The defendants weren't allowed access to lawyers. There are allegations that some were tortured to obtain false confessions. These people are being put on trial for what amounts to treason because Ahmadinejad's regime couldn't handle people questioning their legitimacy. Instead of addressing the questions of legitimacy with openness, they decided to kill a bunch of people, throw some more in jail and torture them. Now they're trying to politically manipulate the situation by having a "trial"? Don't think that this is a trial, or even a court of law, not for one second.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Crumbling Tower

Over the past couple of days, stories about what has happened to the protesters arrested in Iran have begun to emerge. Here in the US, we enjoy great freedom when it comes to protesting being that it is a guaranteed right under our constitution. We can assemble a protest on any sidewalk in any city and expect that the most that would be hurled at us would be insults. Not so in Iran where in the weeks after the recent election many protesters have been killed and many more have been jailed and beaten.

In the wake of the Presidential elections nearly two months past, Ahmadinejad's regime unleashed the Basij militia, it's own political dissent stomping machine, to round up protesters and engage in enough fear mongering to deter any more protesting. The bodies started to pile up early on in the violent crackdown. Despite Iran's complete reporting blackout of the protests, some protesters were able to get coverage out over user input sites like youtube, where the footage of the death of the Iranian girl dubbed "Neda" became the rallying cry of the opposition.

Official numbers from the Iranian government put the death toll at twenty, but independent reports suggest that the true number is over one hundred. Even more shocking news is that bodies showing signs of great abuse have been coming out of the detention centers where protesters are being held. Those who experienced the ordeal and lived through are affraid to tell their tale out of fear of reprisal. But, there are the brave few who have stepped forward to share their stories of horror.

Dark, putrid cells filled past capacity with detainees. Constant beatings from the guards. Various forms of psychological and physical abuse. The abuse got so bad that, once a prominent conservative politician's son was beaten to death, Ayatollah Khamenei had to step in and close the Kahrizak detention center. Instead of this helping the situation, however, the very fact that Iran's supreme leader had to intervene has galvanized the opposition and even sent some conservatives to the other side. The fact of the matter is that it should never have gotten to the point where a detention center needed to be closed.

The gut check here is interesting. Ahmadinejad's regime seems to have blinked and taken a step back. They realize that their brutal tactics are now turning the people against them and it certainly hasn't been long enough for people to forget about the accusations of corruption and fraud during the Presidential election. Iran is sure to get criticism from all sides, internationally, now that the details of protester abuses are coming out. The internal pressure is building and the political opposition doesn't appear to be letting up. Frankly, Ahmadinejad and Khamenei are out of options. They can't continue the violent crackdown because it will just turn more of their allies against them. They can't keep blaming foreign influences (read: the West) for their political turmoil because it's becoming clear that it is self-inflicted. They can't keep dodging questions of legitimacy because it's empowering the opposition. They have only one move left: start making concessions.

Monday, July 27, 2009

Between a Rock and a Hard Place

On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for anyone drops to zero. This quote from the movie Fight Club is literally and conceptually applicable to any international crisis situation, especially the current situation between Iran and Israel. It's always a question of time, like, given enough time, anyone with means and motive will carry out an action. Plug in Iran and nuclear weapons and, given enough time, Iran will develop nuclear weapons because they have the means and the motive. The only thing that is deceptively unclear is the true motive.

If you ask any one person what they think about Iran, nukes, and Israel, the ensuing conversation is going to be the same thing every time. Iran is evil; they're trying to get nukes to wipe Israel off the planet. Of course you can't blame anyone for thinking that, the second half of that statement looks like a direct quote from an Ahmadinejad speach. But, consider this: if you look at a map of the Middle East, Iran is situated directly between Iraq and Afghanistan, currently home to thousands of US troops. Iran has also been the subject of much sabre rattling over the past five or so years. Factor in the long running conflict between Israel and surrounding hardline Islamic regimes and you've got a massive powder keg that can be set off by any of three sparks: US aggression from Iraq or Afghanistan, Israeli first strike, or Iran obtaining nuclear weapons.

The question remains though, is Iran seeking nuclear weapons in order to protect themselves a la North Korea or is Iran really going to bomb Israel? The answer doesn't even matter because Israel isn't going to sit around and wait to find out. The second they have hard evidence that Iran is dangerously close to having a bomb ready to go, past the proverbial point of no return, Israel will go weapons hot on a first strike and never look back, especially now that Netanyahu is running things. The question then becomes how to do we dump water on the fuse before the powderkeg blows?

Obama is pushing the international effort as the peaceful solution that doesn't utilized inflammatory political rhetoric. Today, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates outlined the next step if Iran continues to buck international demands that it return to the negotiating table, that being hard sanctions (a shot at Iran's means of obtaining the materials neccessary to develop nuclear weapons). Gates' announcement came on a visit to Israel, after which Netanyahu reaffirmed Israel's "all options on the table" stance. The thing is, Israel doesn't like leaving these types of situations up to chance, like the chance that Russia (Iran's supplier of nuclear materials and technologies) would veto any resolution on new sanctions or the chance that sanctions would just further resolve Iran to obtaining nuclear weapons.

The gut check here is scary. Of the three most likely scenarios for nuclear war (India/Pakistan, North Korea, and the Middle East), only one can happen first on a timeline. That being said, the building pressure between Iran and Israel is definitely the most likely scenario for a breakout regional conflict. If nuclear weapons are thrown in the mix, then it will become the most likely scenario for nuclear conflict. The only way to stop an Israeli first strike is to somehow get Iran to cease and desist nuclear weapons development and prove that they are doing so. Obama's diplomatic overtures combined with the democratic internal turmoil Iran is currently experiencing are putting Ahmadinejad's regime between a rock and a hard place in terms of their policy toward international oversight of their nuclear program. Adding harsher sanctions or even just the threat of harsher sanctions will act like turning up the thermostat. The question is, will Iran choose the path that resolves conflict or the path that leads to confrontation?